Assessment of Nature-Related Risks and Opportunities (TNFD)
With the increasing impact of global economic activities on ecosystems, in addition to the risks and opportunities related to climate change, the issue of biodiversity loss has gradually become the focus of stakeholders.
In 2024, Compal has followed the LEAP methodology recommended by The Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD) to complete the biodiversity spatial locating analysis of its own plants and tier 1 suppliers production bases (see Biodiversity Spatial Locating Analysis for details), and used The ENCORE database analyzes the countries and industries in the value chain to identify the dependencies and impacts of the value chain on ecosystem services and impact drivers (see Dependencies and Impacts Analysis for details).
Finally, through the analysis of Compal's own plants, production sites of tier 1 suppliers and the industry categories of its downstream customers, we analyzed the relevance of nature-related physical risks (e.g., water shortages), transition risks (e.g., media shortages) and systemic risks (e.g., Labor/ Human Rights) to the value chain in order to identify a list of Compal's value chain-related nature-related risks, which would serve as the basis for the subsequent refinement of the analysis of the dependency and impact pathways, and the assessment of the materiality risks (see the list of nature-related risks and opportunities in the following).
Compal plans to follow the mitigation hierarchy (avoid, reduce, restore, regenerate, transform) to achieve no net loss (NNL). In summary, through the implementation of the TNFD framework, Compal is able to gain a deeper understanding of the interaction and impact of the natural environment, and develop a set of proactive and effective risk and opportunity responses, which not only mitigates negative impact on the natural environment, but also provides long-term economic benefits and competitive advantages.
Biodiversity Spatial Locating Analysis
Compal follows the LEAP methodology recommended by The Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD) to perform biodiversity spatial locating analysis. The assessment scope covers its own plants and tier 1 suppliers production bases. Through the geographical location information of the plant, a circle with a diameter of 2.5km and 5km is drawn with the plant as the center point as the assessment boundary to analyze whether the own plant and the tier 1 suppliers base are in contact with important biodiversity areas.
According to the results of this locating analysis, CEA, CEB and Compal USA (Indiana) ranked in the top three priority locations among all 19 Compal operating sites. These three plant areas were listed as important areas (material locations) for monitoring and management. In terms of supplier management, the purchase amount and locating analysis results will be considered at the same time, and the biodiversity policy will be promoted to the top suppliers.
In the future, Compal will focus on the highly sensitive areas analyzed to formulate further management measures to reduce the impact of the enterprise on biodiversity by using the AR3T action framework: Avoid, Reduce, Restore, Regenerate, and Transform.
Dependencies and Impacts Analysis
Compal uses ENCORE database combined with EXIOBASE data to conduct dependencies and impacts analysis. First, Compal and its suppliers are analyzed by ENCORE according to their industries, and the ecosystem services and impact drivers related to each industry are initially identified. Then, using the EXIOBASE input-output model, we performed the dependency and influence significance assessment on the highly relevant ecosystem services and impact drivers listed in ENCORE, and finally, based on the results of the aforementioned comprehensive analysis, we completed the dependencies and impacts significance analysis of Compal and its suppliers by industry.
1. Dependencies Analysis
Compal analyzed the dependence of PCBG and SDBG business groups on their own operations and suppliers, and the results show that both business groups and their suppliers have a higher degree of dependence on the ecosystem services of " provisioning services - material" and "regulating and supporting services - regulating flow", and the detailed results are shown in Fig. 5 and Fig. 6.
2. Impacts Analysis
The impacts analysis results of Compal PCBG and SDBG and their suppliers show that they have a greater impact on the impact drivers of " overconsumption of resources ", "climate change", and "pollution", and the detailed results are shown in Fig. 7 and Fig. 8.
List of Nature-related Risks and Opportunities
Compal uses the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) Biodiversity Risk Filter (WWF BRF) to analyze different biodiversity risk issues and Compal own plants and its tier 1 suppliers production bases and downstream industry categories value chain relevance. Based on the correlation ranking results, Compal selected highly relevant risk issues, and then explained the potential impact of the risk issues based on different value chain positions, which served as the basis for subsequent analysis of the dependence and impact pathways of each plant.
In addition, to fully identify the impact of nature on the value chain, Compal further conducted a risk relevance analysis. Based on the results, Compal mapped highly relevant risk issues to the list of opportunity issues outlined in the TNFD framework. This initial identification revealed potential nature-related opportunities at various positions within Compal’s value chain. The selected opportunity issues were then described in terms of their potential positive impacts according to their respective value chain positions. For detailed information, please see Table 1: Compal Value Chain Biodiversity Risks and Opportunities List.
Compal has long been paying attention to the impact of nature-related risks and opportunities on operations, and released the "Biodiversity and No Deforestation Policy" in 2023, incorporating Compal's commitment to biodiversity and the goal of no net loss (NNL), and encourage suppliers and business partners to plan and conduct biodiversity risk assessments, and encourage them to take measures that can reduce ecological impact. In addition, in order to respond to biodiversity risks in advance, Compal has included the identified risk issues into the company's overall risk management structure to ensure that Compal can maintain operational resilience and sustainable development when facing nature-related challenges and continue to grow in operational scale. While maintaining balance with the natural environment.
Table 1: Compal Value Chain Biodiversity Risks and Opportunities List
Nature-Related Risks |
Nature-Related Opportunities |
||||
Assessment Aspect |
Risk Category |
Risk Name |
Risk Relevance Rating |
Risk Description |
Opportunity Description |
Supply Chain |
Physical Risks |
Water shortages |
M* |
Water shortages may lead to disruptions in the supply chain production, affecting the water demand for manufacturing processed and plant cooling systems of components, circuit boards, and chip suppliers. This situation may lead to increased procurement costs for Compal and prompt the search for alternative suppliers. |
*Resource efficiency: Suppliers promote process optimization and various water-saving actions of plants to improve water resource efficiency. By implementing water recycling and reuse technologies, they reduce reliance on water resources, thereby mitigating the potential impact of water shortages on cooling system operations and production output. This enhances the stability of Compal’s supply chain. |
Physical Risks |
Extremely high temperature |
H |
Suppliers’ utilization of natural resources can impact surrounding ecosystem services, leading to a decline in ecosystem regulation capabilities. During extreme high temperatures, increased use of cooling air conditioning to maintain indoor temperatures can escalate energy consumption. This can potentially lead to equipment overheating, causing production interruptions, and even affecting the health and safety of outdoor field workers. Supply chain disruptions and increased energy consumption lead to higher production costs for suppliers, which in turn increases Compal's procurement costs. |
*Ecosystem protection, restoration, and regeneration: Implement incentive measures and encourage suppliers to invest in green infrastructure around their plants, such as landscaping, rooftop greening, and urban forests. These initiatives not only help reduce the ambient temperature around the plant but also promote habitat restoration and regeneration, enhancing suppliers’ resilience to extreme heat. |
|
Physical Risks |
Tropical cyclone |
VH |
Suppliers’ utilization of natural resources can impact surrounding ecosystem services, leading to a decline in ecosystem regulation capabilities. |
*Ecosystem protection, restoration, and regeneration: Encourage suppliers to participate in or initiate ecological restoration projects, such as planting trees and protecting coastal mangroves, which can not only help regulate regional climates and reduce the impact of tropical cyclones on industrial areas, but also strengthen ecosystem regulation capabilities. |
|
Physical Risks |
Pollution |
VH |
The wastewater, air pollution emissions, and solid waste generated during the supplier's production and operations may lead to environmental degradation in the surrounding area and water quality deterioration. This can impact ecosystems and ecosystem services. This could potentially lead to public health concerns, legal liabilities, lawsuits, and reputational damage risks. |
*Resource efficiency : Call on suppliers to invest in R&D, as well as adopting best available control technologies, can help reduce emissions of harmful pollutants. This proactive approach can mitigate risks associated with fines, lawsuits, and reputational damage. |
|
Systemic risk |
Labor/Human rights |
H |
Suppliers’ utilization of natural resources can impact ecosystem regulation capabilities. Inadequate human rights management measures by suppliers may increase workplace hazards, posing risks to employee health and safety, reducing quality of life. This can lead to risks like social equity, food security, and ecological disasters, facing legal penalties and suspension risks, promoting Compal to seek alternative suppliers and increase procurement costs. |
*Reputation: Suppliers are required to formulate and implement comprehensive policies and procedures for the protection of labor rights and interests. This includes providing excellent working conditions, robust workplace health and safety management measures, and establishing mechanisms for employee complaints and feedback. These efforts aim to prevent, mitigate, or eliminate negative impacts on employees’ physical and mental health, thereby enhancing corporate reputation and regulatory compliance within the supply chain. This approach contributes to maintaining long-term partnerships and supply chain stability for Compal. |
|
Transition risk |
Media supervision |
H |
If suppliers ignore environmental damage, it can attract media attention and result in negative news coverage, damaging corporate image and reputation. This loss of public trust may lead to legal challenges, tarnishing Compal’s reputation and potentially necessitating the search of alternative suppliers. |
*Reputation: Strengthen suppliers' compliance with environmental and social regulations involves using transparent and responsible communication methods to respond positively to media reports. This ensures that external messaging fully reflects the Company’s commitment and actions towards environmental and social responsibility. Proactively disclosing management performance in environmental and social compliance further enhances stability and reputation within Compal’s supply chain. |
|
Self-operation |
Physical Risks |
Water shortages |
M* |
Compal is not a high water-consuming industry, and water resources are only used for general domestic water, not in manufacturing processes. If there is a water shortage issue, it could affect the operation of the plant’s cooling and air conditioning systems, as well as employees’ domestic water usage. This might necessitate seeking alternative water sources, leading to increased costs. |
*Resource efficiency: Compal adopts various strategies to improve water resource efficiency, aiming to mitigate the potential impact of water shortages on cooling and air conditioning systems, as well as on employees’ domestic water usage. These efforts help reduce the additional costs associated with seeking alternative water sources. |
Physical Risks |
Extremely high temperature |
H |
Compal’s operations require the use of natural resources, which can impact surrounding ecosystem services and lead to a decline in ecosystem regulation capabilities. During extreme high temperatures, increased use of cooling and air conditioning to maintain indoor temperatures can escalate energy consumption and lead to higher energy costs. |
*Ecosystem protection, restoration, and regeneration: Invest in green infrastructure around Compal’s operational sites, such as green vegetation, green roofs, urban forests, or converting existing plants into green facilities, can help reduce ambient temperatures around the sites. Additionally, these efforts promote the restoration and regeneration of natural habitats. |
|
Physical Risks |
Tropical cyclone |
H |
Compal’s operations require use of natural resources, which can impact surrounding ecosystem services and lead to a decline in ecosystem regulation capabilities. This can exacerbate the impact of tropical cyclones, increasing the likelihood of plant damage, equipment loss, and production disruptions. Additionally, it may pose risks such as casualties and increased safety hazards for employees. If there are production interruption and transportation difficulties, it can also affect Compal’s product deliveries, leading to increased maintenance costs and a decline in revenue. |
*Ecosystem protection, restoration, and regeneration: Participate in or initiate ecological restoration projects, such as planting trees and protecting coastal mangroves, to help regulate regional climate, reduce the impact of tropical cyclones on industrial areas, and contribute positively to biodiversity. |
|
Physical Risks |
Pollution |
H |
Compal does not belong to industries with high pollution emissions. However, the wastewater, air pollution emissions, and solid waste generated during its operations can still contribute to environmental degradation in the surrounding area and deterioration of water quality. This may impact ecosystems, potentially leading to public health concerns or legal liabilities. Consequently, we face risks such as fines, lawsuits, and reputational damage. |
* Resource efficiency: Compal invests in the best available technologies for the prevention and control of various environmental pollution, aiming to maximize reduction or elimination of negative environmental impacts. |
|
Downstream |
Physical Risks |
Water shortages |
M* |
When facing water shortages, brand owners may experience increased operational costs. If they neglect water shortage issues, it can impact their corporate image and raise public concerns about their environmental policies. This pressure may force them to strengthen water resource management requirements across their supply chains. As a result, Compal may need to comply with brand requirements to reduce product water footprints, which can increase costs related to water-saving measures and procurement. |
*Resource efficiency: Compal adopts various strategies to improve water resource efficiency and implements supplier water management policies to reduce the water footprint of products. This approach aims to capitalize on business opportunities by meeting brand requirements for water conservation, thereby establishing long-term partnerships. |
Physical Risks |
Extremely high temperature |
H |
Value chain's utilization of natural resources can impacts global ecosystem services, leading to a decline in ecosystem regulation capabilities. Brand owners facing extreme high temperature risks may experience increased energy consumption for air conditioning to maintain indoor temperatures. To address this risk, brand owners may further strengthen sustainable supply chain management, requiring Compal to improve energy efficiency and align with their energy-saving goals. Failure to comply may result in losing additional business opportunities. |
*Resource efficiency: If Compal invests in improving plant energy efficiency through upgrading existing equipment and optimizing production processes to reduce energy consumption during operations, it will be well-positioned to gain customer trust by surpassing industry standards when brand owners require energy-saving specifications in the future. |
|
Physical Risks |
Tropical cyclone |
H |
Value chain’s utilization of natural resources impacts global ecosystem services, leading to an increased frequency of extreme weather events and a decline in ecosystem regulation capabilities. The operation of brand owners or the transportation within their supply chain can be disrupted by tropical cyclones, affecting product delivery. To mitigate this risk, brands may further require Compal to enhance its disaster prevention capabilities. |
*Ecosystem protection, restoration, and regeneration: Participate in or initiate ecological restoration projects, such as planting trees and protecting coastal mangroves, helps regulate local climates, reduce the impact of typhoons on brand owners’ operational sites or supply chain transport, and contributes positively to biodiversity. |
|
Physical Risks |
Pollution |
H |
Environmental pollution caused by electronic product waste may cause brand owners to face public and regulatory pressure. This may compel brands to enhance sustainability of their product designs, expand the use of recycled materials, or implement product recycling mechanisms. Consequently, they might require Compal to align with these goals to mitigate the environmental impact and pollution of products at the disposal stage. |
*Resource efficiency: If Compal collaborates proactively with brand owners to enhance sustainable product design, expand the use of recycled materials, or jointly implement product recycling mechanisms, it will not only reduce the negative environmental impact of electronic waste across the value chain but also strengthen Compal’s competitiveness and enhance trust among brand customers. This could lead to opportunities for revenue growth. |
*Note: According to the analysis results, the physical risk issue "water shortage" is not highly relevant. However, according to the dependence and impact analysis results, the corresponding water resources ecosystem services in "Provisioning Services - Materials" are highly dependent. Therefore, Compal included this issue in the list of risk issues.
Updated on July 17, 2024